[ckan-dev] Organizations Merge

Sean Hammond sean.hammond at okfn.org
Tue Sep 18 15:00:45 UTC 2012


> I have to say that I remain unhappy with this whole patch set.
> 
> To me organisations and groups are pretty much the same the only
> differences being that datasets are owned by a single organisation which
> affects the authorisation of users accessing/changing that dataset
> 
> maybe that is an oversimplification but I cannot see any other real
> difference (maybe the dataset view gets altered due to the org it is owned
> by)
> 
> as we already have different group types then why not just use this
> functionality?
> 
> This feels like quite a simple change whereas the branch seems to be just
> lots of code duplication for no gain

Another option would be to just rename groups in core to organizations
and change them to behave like organizations do in the spec, because
impression I get is that organizations with organization auth is the
core feature that everyone wants, not groups. Or don't even bother to
rename them, just leave them being called groups, and don't use the word
organization. Main problem with this is the number of tests that would
have to be rewritten.




More information about the ckan-dev mailing list